Welcome to the Curriculum & Leadership Journal website.
To receive our fortnightly Email Alert,
please click on the blue menu item below.
Curriculum & Leadership Journal
An electronic journal for leaders in education
ISSN: 1448-0743
Follow us on twitter

Abstracts

From dismal failure to strong and smart

Autumn 2005; Pages 40–41
Chris Sarra

The author describes steps he took as new principal at Cherbourg State School, Queensland, that have transformed outcomes for its Aboriginal students. On taking up his role he found that attendance, literacy and student behaviour were all very poor, but that many staff attributed these failings to ‘social and cultural complexities’, lack of interest in education by students and parents, and lack of community support for the school. He campaigned among staff and students to raise expectations, demanding higher academic achievement without sacrificing cultural identity. High staff turnover at this time assisted in the transformation of school culture. Students’ attendance levels, application to their academic work, and general behaviour have dramatically improved.

KLA

Subject Headings

Teacher-student relationships
Socially disadvantaged
Social life and customs
School culture
School and community
Queensland
Parent and child
Motivation
Aboriginal students
Aboriginal peoples

An Australian Certificate of Education?

16 March 2005; Page 6
Geoff N Masters

Three steps could be taken to reduce duplication of effort between State and Territory education systems and to permit easier comparisons of students’ results between jurisdictions. Firstly, States and Territories could all rename their existing senior school certificates as the Australian Certificate of Education (ACE) without any immediate change to curriculum or assessment procedures. Systems have already collaborated to produce guidelines for certification of post-compulsory schooling through the ACACA: these guidelines could be developed further to provide the framework of quality standards for a common Year 12 certificate. Secondly, systems could introduce a common aptitude test into the ACE for assessment of cross-curricular skills such as critical thinking. The test could be used to assist moderation of school-based assessments, for selection of students by tertiary institutions, and also in ‘finer-grained study of student and school performances’. Thirdly, ACACA agencies could explore ways to share secondary syllabuses and assessment procedures operating in different jurisdictions. Responsibility for different areas of the senior secondary curriculum could possibly be divided between education authorities.

KLA

Subject Headings

Standards
Senior secondary education
Federal-state relations
Educational planning
Educational certificates
Education policy
Curriculum planning
Assessment

'Oh what would you do Mrs Brown?' Some experiences in teaching about sexuality

Volume 39 Number 1,  2004; Pages 71–91
Jenny Munro, Keith Ballard

The authors examine issues in sexuality education in New Zealand, and present findings from interviews and collaborative work with four women teachers. The curriculum statement Health and Physical Education in the New Zealand Curriculum makes sexuality education a Key Learning Area, covering health, interpersonal relationships and wellbeing (‘haurora’), as well as physical issues. Since its publication, different groups have expressed concern on issues such as teachers’ training needs, resourcing for sexuality education, parents’ rights, accommodation of religious beliefs, and the appropriate age level for commencement of students’ sexuality education. Teachers’ main concern has been how to handle student questions, especially requests for their personal opinions. Female teachers in particular may face provocative behaviour in class by male students. Teachers may need to draw on knowledge from other professions such as counselling, youth work, nursing and medicine. Teachers may also benefit from professional development to encourage critical reflection on their own values and on the purpose of sexuality education. They need to recognise dominant and alternative cultural constructions of sexuality, and the way that they display their own values to students through silences, body language and role modelling as well as through words.

Key Learning Areas

Health and Physical Education

Subject Headings

Teacher-student relationships
Students
Social life and customs
Sex education
School and community
Religion
Professional development
Parent and child
New Zealand
Female teachers
Ethics
Curriculum planning
Education policy
Classroom management
Adolescents

School-to-work transitions: why the United Kingsom's educational ladders always fail to connect

Volume 14 Number 3,  2004; Pages 203–215
Ken Roberts

Post-compulsory school education in Britain has massively expanded over recent decades in the form of tertiary and vocational courses. The desire for higher qualifications has spread from middle-class males to all social strata and both sexes. However, a significant disjuncture remains between education and employment, with young people now ‘seriously overqualified and over-ambitious’ in relation to the number and type of jobs on offer. While youth unemployment is downplayed in official discourse, it continues to exist, concentrated in the same disadvantaged sectors of the community as in past decades. More than 90 per cent of school leavers depart with some qualifications, yet between 12 per cent and 20 per cent have been found to be deficient in basic literacy and numeracy skills, suggesting that schools are not covering these skills adequately. This contradiction lies behind the current debate over declining educational standards in Britain. Schools may be meeting performance targets by entering students in easier subjects. Schools and colleges are encouraged to keep youth in study by funding regimes tying payment to student numbers. While the world’s richest countries also provide the most schooling to their youth, their wealth may be the cause of the education spending, rather than the effect of higher productivity brought about by that schooling. The oversupply of qualifications primarily benefits employers, who are able to attract highly trained people to lower-level jobs. The ‘one sure solution’ to the disjuncture between qualifications and postions is to create a lot more jobs, ‘and if necessary use the public sector to ensure that these are quality jobs’. If this solution is rejected on the grounds of international competitive pressures, about one third of the work force will continue to be subject to a life of poor pay, welfare, and strict policing.

KLA

Subject Headings

Educational planning
Education policy
VET (Vocational Education and Training)
Vocational guidance
Unemployment
Transitions in schooling
Social classes
Economic trends
Great Britain

Let the show go on!

Number 40, Autumn 2005; Pages 15–17
Catherine Fullerton, Beverley Moriarty, Patrick A. Danaher, Geoff Danaher

The Queensland School for Travelling Show Children was established in 2000, and replaced the service provided to Queensland’s travelling community by the School of Distance Education. The school caters for students from Years 1–7, and its physical structure comprises two mobile classrooms, equipped with computers, which are hosted by local schools in the towns that the show happens to be visiting. The school’s students and parents are part of Australia’s travelling community, a subculture which has its own demands, itinerary, traditions and experiences of schooling. For Catherine Fullerton, one of the authors of this article and principal of the school, integrating the school with the life of the community was one of the challenges she had to face and, according to the article, has handled with sensitivity and remarkable insight. The authors describe the challenges which the show community has to confront, the impact schooling their children has on their lives – family, community and work routines – and acknowledges the cultural sensitivities involved in integrating this community with an educational framework which has its own set of cultural priorities.

KLA

Subject Heading

Doing the diagnostic

Number 40, Autumn 2005; Pages 2–4
Ian Whitehead

Ian Whitehead is the principal of a primary school in a socially disadvantaged, regional area of Victoria. In this article he recounts his school’s experiences with Education Department accountability regimes, and how the school community used standardised, state-wide testing, in this case the Achievement Improvement Monitor (AIM) tests, as motivation to improve students’ performance. Whitehead admits that, given the school’s demographics, his school endured a less than glowing review process, but that it brought to the attention of the staff that much more could be done to improve the educational experiences of their students, in particular their male students, who were in the bottom 25 per cent of the state on standardised benchmarks. Whitehead describes the travails of the review process, and the strategies implemented by staff to improve student outcomes.  

KLA

Subject Headings

Leadership
School leadership
Education management
Statistics
Education policy
State schools
Victoria

‘Thinking and play’ in a new way: ideas technology in early childhood

Volume 10 Number 4, Spring 2004; Pages 28–29
Marilyn Fleer

Fleer describes the move away from technology as systems and tool based towards technology that is based on ideas. She suggests that with the shift from an industrial society to a knowledge-based society, there is a need for technology education to value ideas, as opposed to products, and to equip young people with the conceptual thinking skills to participate fully and productively in the new economy. The article contains an outline of the Technology Education Plan – Stage One: 2002–2006, produced by the Commonwealth Department of Education, Science and Training in 2002, and two examples of early childhood educators teaching technology education in ways that encourage and value ideas as ends in themselves.

Key Learning Areas

Technology

Subject Headings

Technology teaching
Education aims and objectives

Caught in the closet: the silencing of sexuality in early childhood education

Volume 10 Number 4, Spring 2004; Pages 20–21
Anthony Semann

Semann draws the reader’s attention to the issues of homophobia and heterosexism in society generally, and to the many discriminatory legal and regulatory provisions which continue to deny families headed by same sex parents the rights afforded to heterosexual families. He points to research which shows an increase in the number of families with same sex parents, and suggests that early childhood services will need to examine their practices and become more inclusive of same sex families in the interests of social justice and equity.

KLA

Subject Headings

Discrimination
Gay and lesbian issues
Early childhood education

Wearing your underpants on the outside: Investigating children’s hero play

Volume 10 Number 4, Spring 2004; Pages 12–14
Patrick OBrien

O’Brien notes the disinclination for adults to encourage children’s superhero play, and exhorts them to become more active in facilitating such activity because it has developmental benefits for children. O’Brien, citing the available literature on the subject of children’s hero play, supports the view that children are able to explore and mediate their reality through fantasy, as they can experience unusual events, simplify situations and avoid the harmful effects of ‘real’ experience by pretending. Adults, and especially early childhood teachers, can facilitate hero play by setting the rules for games, drawing children’s attention to the values of their superheroes, using their games as an opportunity to teach them problem-solving strategies and helping them identify some of the real heroes in their lives. 

KLA

Subject Headings

Early childhood education

Interrupting the cycle of bullying and victimisation in the elementary classroom

Volume 86 Number 4, December 2004; Pages 288–291
Karen Siris, Karen Osterman

This article describes an action research project, centred on the issue of bullying, which was conducted by teachers at a primary school in the state of New York. Aware of bullying behaviour in their classes, the teachers decided to address the psychological needs and emotional wellbeing of the victims in their efforts to overcome the problem. In their initial observations, they found that the students who were being bullied had, for one reason or another, personality traits or psychological needs which made them 'stand out' amongst their peers. The aims of the research project were to identify the students who were being bullied and their needs or emotional deficits, and to create classroom environments in which their emotional and social wellbeing would be fostered. The teachers found that in nearly every respect they were successful in transforming the students' experiences at school when they attempted to meet the students' social and emotional needs by addressing their desire to belong and to be seen as competent and autonomous. Teachers therefore actively ensured that they modelled inclusive behaviour, put in place rules for working in groups, and looked for opportunities for students to display their strengths. The results of the project and the efforts of the researchers are described in detail in the article. 

KLA

Subject Headings

Bullying

Why are we learning this stuff? What is this stuff good for, anyway?

Volume 86 Number 4, December 2004; Pages 282–287
Bob Vavilis, Sheri L. Vavilis

The authors of this article exhort educators to have conversations with students about learning and education. Teachers should not ignore or skip over questions – or even sarcasm – about the relevance of their discipline, disciplinary knowledge or education in general, but instead see them as 'teachable moments', a time to break from the lesson plan and encourage students to have a free and open discussion, even a debate, about their education. In so doing, teachers not only address the immediate inquiry, but they actively encourage students to reflect on a 'philosophy of education', and create an environment in their classrooms where inquiry, debate and dialogue are respected. The authors also note that taking advantage of these moments allows educators to use a constructivist teaching methodology in considering the place of education in students' lives, as it allows students to discover for themselves the meaning and understanding that education brings to their existences. The article contains examples of classroom dialogue from a mathematics class, in which the teacher departed from the lesson plan to consider students' questions about the relevance of the subject matter they were learning.       

KLA

Subject Headings

Education philosophy
Education aims and objectives

Thinking big: a conceptual framework for the study of everything

Volume 86 Number 4, December 2004; Pages 276–281
Marion Brady

Marion Brady suggests that the narrowly defined curriculum, predicated on the academic disciplines, gives students a misleading idea of the way knowledge should be organised. Far from the narrowly compartmentalised view of knowledge, Brady makes a claim for 'generalists' instead of specialists, and for a reconceptualisation of the way knowledge is organised. Brady argues that human beings have an innate conception of the world, and all that needs to be done is for educators to make students aware of this innate conceptual framework. This framework consists of five categories – time, setting, actors, social patterns and assumptions – which Brady argues people bring to understanding any situation. While its component parts can be found in the accepted knowledge disciplines, it, however, is not an interdisciplinary approach as it precedes the disciplines. Brady asserts that it is time for educators and leaders to challenge the 'mile wide and inch deep' curriculum, and to introduce students to a 'seamless' and holistic understanding of knowledge, as to do less would be to continue to propagate a failing system, one that bears very little relevance to helping students solve life's 'big questions', and which forces them to address knowledge in a way that is incompatible with human experience.

KLA

Subject Headings

Education philosophy
Knowledge

Making a match between students and student teachers

16 March 2005; Page 3
Anne-Kathrin Cyrus

The Dusseldorf Skills Forum and the University of Western Sydney have collaborated to develop Learning Choices: Next Generation, a program that addresses the needs of at-risk students. The program also gives student teachers experience in dealing with 'problem' children. Organisations working with at-risk youth can go the Learning Choices website to locate student teachers who have registered with the program and who have interests relevant to the organisation's needs. The UWS allocates time for the student teachers to provide 60 hours of unpaid one-on-one teaching time with the students.

KLA

Subject Headings

Teacher training
Socially disadvantaged

The labour market for Australian teachers

Beth Webster, Mark Wooden, Gary N. Marks

There is a shortage of teachers for maths, physics, chemistry, ICT and technology, LOTE, and in some rural areas. Overseas research indicates that maths and science teachers, and outstanding teachers across disciplines, are more likely than other teachers to leave schools to take up other professions. Maths and science teachers appear to be less attracted than other teachers to the non-pecuniary benefits of the profession, such as enjoyment of contact with children. As a partial solution to these problems, teachers in maths and science should be offered higher pay at all career stages. This incentive should be signalled to undergraduates through formal pay structures. Schools should be able and willing to offer better pay to undersupplied and/or outstanding teachers. The adoption of these solutions is hindered in the government and Catholic sectors through the tradition, reinforced by unions, of matching pay closely to teaching experience. The paper covers issues including the segmentation of the teaching labour market, factors affecting flow between teaching and other professions, the nature of teacher shortages and techniques for estimating them, comparisons of teaching to other professions, teachers' own perceptions of their pay and job satisfaction levels, and techniques to identify high quality teaching.

KLA

Subject Headings

Teaching profession
Teachers' employment
Science teaching
Physics
Mathematics teaching
Languages other than English (LOTE)
Educational planning
Education policy
Economic trends
Chemistry